A recent McGill University study finds that highly caring adults who neglect self-compassion face higher psychological distress. Learn how to balance care.
In September 2026, researchers led by Bassam Khoury of McGill University published a new study in Personality and Individual Differences. The paper examined how compassion directed toward oneself, other people, and animals relates to mental health and well-being.
The research team surveyed more than 1,200 Canadians online to understand their psychological habits. These questionnaires covered individual levels of compassion, stress, anxiety, and depression. The surveys also measured emotional regulation and overall well-being. Participants reported both their compassionate thoughts and their compassionate actions toward themselves, other people, and animals.
The researchers used these varied responses to categorize participants into six distinct compassion profiles. The available coverage of the study did not publish the full names or complete statistical results for all six groups. The primary focus of the findings centered on how the groups compared in their reported levels of psychological distress. This methodology allowed the team to look closely at the balance between internal and external care.
The researchers found clear differences among the groups based on where their compassion was directed. Participants who reported high compassion for other people or animals but low self-compassion showed negative outcomes. This specific group reported more stress, anxiety, and depression than the other analyzed profiles. The findings highlight a vulnerability for adults managing heavy emotional workloads.
Caring for others without matching that care internally leaves individuals exposed to higher psychological strain. Many adults in caregiving or high-demand roles instinctively prioritize external needs over their own maintenance. This constant output without internal replenishment often contributes to understanding cumulative strain. The data suggests that outward care alone does not shield a person from distress.
The most favorable reported psychological outcomes belonged to a different profile. The strongest-performing group combined high self-compassion with high compassion for other people and animals. This specific group reported the lowest anxiety and depression among the six profiles. They also reported the highest levels of overall well-being.
This balanced profile demonstrates that self-focus does not need to replace outward care. The healthiest participants maintained strong empathy for others while also directing that same supportive energy inward. This finding offers validation for midlife adults who feel guilty about taking time for themselves. Taking time for personal rest is a protective habit rather than a selfish choice.
The research team conducted a follow-up assessment with approximately 200 participants three months after the initial survey. They found that the participants' compassion profiles remained largely stable over this short period. The core traits dictating how individuals directed their care did not change significantly. The participants' reported compassionate actions did fluctuate over the same timeframe.
This distinction between traits and actions matters deeply for adults dealing with chronic stress. A person might hold strong compassionate values while having limited capacity to act on them when feeling depleted. Acting on compassionate thoughts requires time, energy, and opportunity. A drop in compassionate behavior might simply signal a temporary lack of resources rather than a permanent personality shift.
Lead researcher Bassam Khoury clarified that the central issue is whether outward concern is accompanied by internal care. He stated that taking care of others while neglecting oneself simply does not offer psychological protection. "If you do things for others but you still don’t take care of yourself, it doesn’t protect you," Khoury said. He noted that self-compassion should be viewed as a foundation for sustainable care.
The McGill team described self-compassion as a practice involving reduced self-criticism and better emotional regulation. Khoury identified four practical elements that make up this internal care. These elements include thinking about oneself without harsh judgment, actively caring for oneself, feeling self-respect, and accepting comfort from others. These components help create a necessary sense of inner safety.
Other clinical experts echoed this interpretation of the findings. Clinical psychologist Paul Gilbert defined compassion as recognizing suffering and having the courage to respond to it. Christopher Germer, a clinical psychologist and Harvard Medical School lecturer, noted the findings align with prior research. He agreed that the study connects self-compassion with broad psychological well-being.
The insights from the McGill study offer practical guidance for adults who habitually prioritize others. These adjustments focus on small habits rather than massive lifestyle changes.
Christopher Germer recommended using a brief body-based reminder to pause during busy days. This involves simply placing a hand over the heart. During this pause, an individual should ask themselves what they need in that exact moment. This practice forces a momentary pivot away from external demands.
Checking in allows an adult to assess their physical, emotional, or relational needs. This small habit interrupts the automatic drive to only solve problems for other people. It requires no special equipment and takes only a few seconds to complete. Regular check-ins can serve as a steady anchor during chaotic schedules.
Bassam Khoury recommended reserving time each day for an activity done solely for oneself. This could mean walking, watching television, or taking a bath. The specific activity matters less than the intention behind it. This time must be protected from outside obligations and household demands.
Many adults view personal time as a reward earned only after all chores are finished. The study suggests viewing this time as critical daily maintenance instead. Protecting this time is a core part of reframing recovery for busy professionals. Without scheduled maintenance, the capacity to care for others eventually degrades.
Highly caring people frequently interpret their own limitations as personal failures. They might use harsh internal language when they feel too tired to help a friend or complete a task. The study connects self-compassion closely with thinking about oneself without this harsh judgment. Changing this internal narrative is a foundational step.
Replacing automatic self-criticism with a neutral description of personal capacity reduces emotional strain. Acknowledging genuine exhaustion is not a weakness. Learning to accept these limitations is a practical method for reducing self-criticism. This shift aligns perfectly with the clinical definition of self-compassion.
Accepting help from others is one of the four components of self-compassion identified by Khoury. This specific element is notoriously difficult for individuals accustomed to being the primary caregiver. Caring adults often reject assistance because they want to avoid burdening their peers. Accepting comfort or assistance is actually a necessary part of the recovery process.
Allowing others to provide support builds resilience and reduces daily isolation. It requires acknowledging that no single person can manage all emotional loads alone. Practicing this acceptance might mean saying yes when a neighbor offers to run an errand. It could also mean seeking professional therapy for persistent negative self-beliefs.
The McGill study provides valuable insights, but its observational design carries distinct limitations. The researchers grouped people based on self-reported patterns and compared their psychological outcomes. This structure shows associations, but it cannot prove that low self-compassion causes anxiety or depression. Psychological distress might erode self-compassion, or other external factors might influence both.
The research sample was mainly female and mostly consisted of English-speaking Canadians. Khoury noted that future research should use larger and more diverse samples from different countries. The available coverage does not state that the study directly measured occupational burnout, compassion fatigue, or sleep quality. The findings support a focused interpretation that balanced compassion is associated with better psychological functioning.
The McGill team is currently developing a new intervention called Embodied and Embedded Mindfulness and Compassion. This program, known as EEMC, aims to reduce suffering and improve overall well-being. It relies on mindfulness and a broader concept of compassion that includes the self, nature, and the living world. This developing program highlights a clinical shift toward treating compassion as a comprehensive ecosystem.
As researchers continue testing interventions like the EEMC program, the medical understanding of recovery continues to evolve. The data increasingly suggests that the ability to care for others relies entirely on a foundation of internal maintenance. How might our long-term approaches to midlife recovery change when we finally treat personal care not as a luxury, but as a biological requirement for sustaining compassion?
Balancing the heavy emotional demands of caregiving with personal recovery needs frequently leaves caring adults feeling guilty for prioritizing themselves, and having Relaxopia interpret the clinical science changes how you view personal maintenance. We clarify the physiological evidence behind stress and rest to help you address difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep without adding guilt to your routine.
Stay connected for research-led guidance on sleep quality, stress, circadian rhythm, recovery, fatigue and everyday energy. Clear ideas for adults 35+ who want to sleep better, recover more fully and feel more capable through the day.
Explore practical guidance on sleep, stress and recovery without chasing every new hack, device or promise.
explore the blog